Why two Vaporizers produce different amounts at the same temperature
Share
Set two Vaporizer devices to the same temperature, give them the same material—and they still produce different amounts. This has been measured in a laboratory, with a 28-percentage-point difference between the best and worst device. This article explains the design factors behind this difference and what makes it larger or smaller during use.
Technical article · Approx. 10-minute read · All figures are supported by primary sources and can be verified individually at the end · Last updated: August 2026
Contents
1 · Yield is the efficiency of a vaporizer
Every machine that transforms something has an efficiency rating. For a heat pump, it is the ratio of electricity used to heat produced; for an espresso machine, it is the proportion of soluble compounds that actually ends up in the cup. For a Vaporizer, it is the yield: the proportion of the active ingredient present in the material that the device transfers into the gas phase. An 80 percent yield means that four-fifths end up in the vapor and one-fifth remains in the plant material.
It is important to understand what this does not mean. Yield is a laboratory value and describes only the device’s performance. It is measured as follows: Under controlled conditions, the device fills a balloon, whose contents are then chemically analyzed. What is lost again when exhaling or not absorbed by the lungs depends on the person, not the device—and is therefore not covered in this article.
That is precisely why it is so useful: It is the only metric for which different Vaporizer devices have been measured directly against one another under identical conditions. No spec sheet offers anything comparable.
2 · The measurements: five devices compared
The most informative study on this topic was conducted by Lanz and colleagues and published in 2016 in PLoS ONE, an open-access journal.[1] Five commercially available devices were tested. Each received the same material and – where adjustable – was set to the same temperature of 210 °C. The researchers then measured how much THC and CBD actually made it into the vapor.
Table 1 · Active compound yield in the vapor, measured at a consistent 210 °C. All values from Lanz et al. 2016.[1] For anonymization, see the note below the table.
| Device | Heating method | THC | CBD | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Device A | Primarily convection | 82,7 % | 70,0 % | Best result in the test lineup – and also the cheapest, most compact device |
| Device B | Hybrid, desktop | 66,8 % | 56,1 % | Second-best result |
| Device C | Convection, desktop | 58,4 % | 51,4 % | Significantly more expensive than device A, but ranked mid-range |
| Device D | Gas-powered | 55,9 % | 45,9 % | No temperature control; combustion was observed during testing |
| Device E | Conduction, portable | 54,6 % | 56,7 % | Lowest THC result, but mid-range for CBD |
Two things are worth a second look. First, the best-performing device wasn’t the most expensive, but a compact portable one. So price says little about yield. Second, the gap between the best and worst results is 28 percentage points – with identical material and temperature. The difference comes down entirely to design.
3 · The proportion that never leaves the chamber
Every yield figure has a flip side: What doesn’t go into the vapor remains in the material. At 82.7 percent yield, that’s 17.3 percent; at 54.6 percent, a full 45.4 percent. Almost half.
Figure 1 · What goes from a load into the vapor
Best and weakest device in the comparison, based on the THC content. After Lanz et al. 2016.[1]
4 · What the difference means in practice
The yield values can be used to directly calculate how much material two devices need for the same result. The calculation is simple division: 82.7 divided by 54.6 equals 1.51. So the weakest device has to use one and a half times as much to get the same amount of active ingredient into the vapor.
Figure 2 · Material used for the same result
Relative representation, calculated from the yield values of 82.7% and 54.6%.[1]
This is what the relationship looks like across the entire test group. The right-hand column indicates how much material a device has to use relative to the best result to achieve the same output.
Table 2 · What the relative yield values mean. All figures calculated from Table 1.
| Device | Yield | remains in the material | Material used relative to |
|---|---|---|---|
| Device A | 82,7 % | 17,3 % | 100 % |
| Device B | 66,8 % | 33,2 % | 124 % |
| Device C | 58,4 % | 41,6 % | 142 % |
| Device D | 55,9 % | 44,1 % | 148 % |
| Device E | 54,6 % | 45,4 % | 151 % |
The gap between the mid-range devices is small, while the gap at the top is large. The difference in material use between Device B and Device E is only 27 percentage points - but the gap between Device A and the rest of the field is at least 24. In other words: there is no gentle slope, but an outlier at the top.
5 · Why almost nothing is lost: decarboxylation
In the fresh plant, the active compound is not present in its active form at all, but as an acid—THCA instead of THC. This acid form has virtually no effect. Heat first removes a carbon dioxide molecule, producing the active compound. This process is called decarboxylation.
How quickly and completely this happens depends on temperature and time. A research group systematically measured this relationship in 2016.[4] More important in practice, however, is what actually happens in the device: In a comparison test from the same year, electrically heated, temperature-controlled devices achieved conversion rates of at least 97 percent.[1]
This is good news and is rarely mentioned: Virtually nothing is lost at this stage. Anyone who “activates” their material in an oven beforehand is doing so for other uses; it isn’t necessary for the Vaporizer, because the device takes care of it during heating anyway.
6 · What changes the yield during use
Temperature is the biggest lever. And it works in both directions. Lower is not automatically better: In a 2009 study, the ratio of active compounds to unwanted by-products was worst at 170 °C out of all the vaporization conditions tested; it was better at 200 and 230 °C.[3] The combustion threshold sets the upper limit. For a detailed look at which temperatures work best for what, see the temperature article in this series.
Grind size determines the surface area. The finer the material, the more surface area heat can act on. With convection devices, where hot air flows through the material, grinding evenly is therefore noticeably more important than with devices that have a heated chamber wall. However, too fine a grind is also not ideal, as it can block the airflow.
The fill level works in both directions. A device study as early as 2006 tested different amounts of material, so the fill level has long been known as a factor.[5] In practice, a chamber that is too loosely packed lets air flow past the sides, while one that is packed too tightly restricts it. With convection and hybrid devices, a loose to medium fill usually works best.
Draw speed matters especially with convection. That's where heat is generated in the airflow - anyone who draws quickly sends air through the material that has had less time to warm up. Slow, steady draws therefore usually deliver more. The article on heating principles explains which principle your device uses.
Table 3 · An overview of the adjustment factors, sorted by effect.
| Adjustment | What it affects | Supported by | Effort |
|---|---|---|---|
| Temperature | Determines how much active ingredient is released and how clean the ratio to by-products is | Measurement series at 170 / 200 / 230 °C[3] | none |
| Device choice | 28 percentage-point difference at identical settings | Device comparison at 210 °C[1] | one-time purchase |
| Grind size | More surface area for heat transfer | Based on physics, not measured for specific devices | a grinder |
| Fill amount | Controls how evenly air flows through the material | studied as a factor[5] | none |
| Draw speed | With convection, determines how hot the air is when it reaches the material | Based on physics, not measured for specific devices | none |
7 · Where the numbers end
This article comes with three caveats to help put the figures in perspective.
First, measurements were taken in a laboratory, not a living room. The devices filled a balloon under controlled conditions. In everyday use, grind size, fill amount, drawing technique, and material moisture also come into play - all factors that can shift the results in either direction.
Second, the study dates from 2016, and the tested devices' successor models were not measured. The rankings from that time cannot be applied to today's devices without further testing.
Third, yield is not the only reason to choose a Vaporizer, and probably not even the most important one. The first comparative laboratory analysis in 2004 found only three accompanying compounds alongside the active ingredients in the vapor - the smoke from the same sample contained more than 111.[2] For more on the composition of vapor, see the detailed article.
What remains is still an unusually clear finding: Two devices with identical settings differed by 28 percentage points. Few other properties of a Vaporizer show a difference measured so clearly - and so little a matter of taste.
8 · Frequently Asked Questions
Why do devices differ at all when the temperature is the same?
Because the set temperature is only a target value. What matters is how much heat actually reaches the material, how evenly it is distributed, and how the airflow moves through the chamber. That’s what distinguishes two designs, even when both displays show the same number.
How big is the difference between two devices?
In the 2016 lab test, the difference in yield between the best and worst results was 28 percentage points.[1] In other words, the least effective device needed around 50 percent more material to achieve the same result. However, these figures are from devices made in 2016 and don’t apply to today’s models.
Is an expensive device automatically more efficient?
No. In the 2016 lab test, the cheapest, most compact device came out on top, while a significantly more expensive desktop device ranked in the middle.[1] Design, not price, is what matters.
Can I test my device’s yield myself?
That’s not useful. The published values come from chromatographic analyses in a lab, where the chamber contents were quantified before and after use. You can’t replicate this at home—visible discoloration or smell don’t reliably indicate the actual amount remaining.
Do I need to activate my material beforehand?
Not for the Vaporizer. The acid form converts to the active form as the device heats up; rates of at least 97 percent were measured in temperature-controlled devices.[1]
Does a low temperature produce a higher yield?
No, quite the opposite. In the 2009 test series, the ratio of active compounds to byproducts was worst at 170 °C and better at 200 and 230 °C.[3] Very low temperatures produce plenty of flavor, but little active compound.
Devices where yield takes center stage
The article above deliberately mentions neither products nor device names from the study. Instead, it describes the features that the measurement data show to be important: a temperature that can be finely adjusted and then maintained, and an airflow path that carries air evenly through the material. These are devices from our range that address exactly these points through their design. We explicitly do not provide yield values from the study for them—different devices were tested at a different time.
Precisely adjustable

Arizer Solo 3 Version 2.0
Mostly convection-based, with an all-glass vapor path and a temperature adjustable from 40 to 220 °C in one-degree increments. This lets you control the temperature as precisely as Section 6 recommends.
View Solo 3 →
Storz & Bickel Plenty
A desktop hybrid combining a preheated chamber and airflow, with a stainless steel cooling coil instead of plastic in the vapor path. Seven temperature settings between 130 and 202 °C cover the range discussed in Section 6.
View Plenty →With temperature settings, airflow control, or an app

Storz & Bickel Venty
Precisely adjustable from 40 to 210 °C, plus continuously adjustable airflow up to 20 liters per minute. Together, these address exactly the two factors from Section 6 that make the biggest difference in everyday use: temperature and draw speed.
View Venty →
Storz & Bickel Crafty+
The more affordable entry point into the same technology: hybrid heating with a ceramic-coated chamber, three preset temperatures of 180, 195, and 210 °C, and finer adjustment via the app. The three settings practically replicate the stepped approach described in Section 6.
View Crafty+ →Sources
- Lanz C., Mattsson J., Soydaner U., Brenneisen R. (2016): Medicinal Cannabis: In Vitro Validation of Vaporizers for the Smoke-Free Inhalation of Cannabis. PLoS ONE 11(1): e0147286. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0147286 – Primary source for all yield values (54.6–82.7%) and decarboxylation rates. Freely accessible.
- Gieringer D., St. Laurent J., Goodrich S. (2004): Cannabis Vaporizer Combines Efficient Delivery of THC with Effective Suppression of Pyrolytic Compounds. Journal of Cannabis Therapeutics 4(1): 7–27. DOI: 10.1300/J175v04n01_02 – Primary source for the comparison of over 111 compounds in smoke versus three in vapor.
- Pomahacova B., Van der Kooy F., Verpoorte R. (2009): Cannabis smoke condensate III: the cannabinoid content of vaporised Cannabis sativa. Inhalation Toxicology 21(13): 1108–1112. DOI: 10.3109/08958370902748559 – Primary source for the temperature series 170 / 200 / 230 °C.
- Wang M., Wang Y.-H., Avula B., Radwan M. M., Wanas A. S., van Antwerp J., Parcher J. F., ElSohly M. A., Khan I. A. (2016): Decarboxylation Study of Acidic Cannabinoids: A Novel Approach Using Ultra-High-Performance Supercritical Fluid Chromatography/Photodiode Array-Mass Spectrometry. Cannabis and Cannabinoid Research 1(1): 262–271. DOI: 10.1089/can.2016.0020 – Primary source for decarboxylation kinetics.
- Hazekamp A., Ruhaak R., Zuurman L., van Gerven J., Verpoorte R. (2006): Evaluation of a vaporizing device (Volcano) for the pulmonary administration of tetrahydrocannabinol. Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences 95(6): 1308–1317. DOI: 10.1002/jps.20574 – Examined, among other things, the effect of different filling amounts.
Note: This article is intended to provide technical and scientific information about how vaporizers work and does not make any claims about the consumption of specific substances. The use of vaporizers and handling of the substances mentioned are subject to applicable laws and regulations. All yield and temperature values are from the cited literature and were determined under laboratory conditions; they are reference values and do not guarantee the performance of any particular device. The ratios in Section 4 are calculated from these laboratory values and indicate an order of magnitude, not savings guaranteed in everyday use.